Answering four dilemmas about Hinduism

Answering four dilemmas about Hinduism

What are the draw-backs of Hinduism apart from idol-worship?

Why do you write “apart from idol worship”? Too much Christian brainwashing that idols are just stone? Hindus consider the whole universe alive, as ultimately Brahman. Nothing wrong in taking the help of a ‘form’, a murthi, to feel closer to the Divine by worshipping it.

Coming to the original question: there are no drawbacks in Hindu Dharma, since it is a genuine, outer and inner enquiry into what is true about us and the universe and helpful for a fulfilling life.  The truth is non-negotiable, but rules for society are flexible. In the last chapter of Manu Smriti for example, it is mentioned that the rules can be changed by a group of either three or even one knowledgeable Brahmins according to the times. (Manu Smriti XII. 112/113)


However, since in the last 2000 years dogmatic religions appeared on the scene which make unsubstantiated claims about ‘truth’, and are highly aggressive in trying to get the whole world believe what they claim as truth, Hinduism proved to be too generous and good natured. It did not suspect that people could cheat others in the name of truth. Its tenet “Truth is one, the wise call it by many names” is applicable only to ‘well meaning’ claims about truth, not incredible dogmas which are pushed by hook or crook meant to dull the intellect and gain worldly power.

Unfortunately, British education weaned Indians away from knowing what their tradition is, by not letting them know their Sanskrit scriptures. So drawbacks are with Indians: first, many Indians wrongly believe that Hinduism is ‘inferior” due to the British brainwashing and second, even if they realize that it is not so, they find it hard to explain the advantages of Hinduism, as they know too little, and slip away into western lifestyle (which obviously is a failed model) or many even to western religions which tend to produce hypocrites.

Is it ok for a Hindu to eat beef?

I assume you are a Hindu. In that case, do you really have to ask this question here on quora? Can’t you ask your conscience? Have you ever looked into the eyes of a cow (or goat, or chicken)?

We westerners were indoctrinated by Christian tenets (and Muslims by Islamic tenets) that nature including animals is there to serve man who is considered ‘the crown of creation”. The result is a brutal yet unnecessary bloodbath all over the world of billions animals slaughtered daily (alone in US some 90,000 cows daily), often skinned while still alive. It is considered “normal”.


Do we have the moral right to do this? Hindu Dharma requires using one’s intelligence. It is not a fixed belief system, like Christianity and Islam.
Your ancestors discovered that a cow particularly is like a mother, gentle and giving, everything the cow gives is useful, including its urine and dung. Who would kill her? Who would kill any animal unless necessary for whatever reasons?

Humanity would be more human and ecology would also benefit greatly if this massive brutal slaughter were at least reduced if not fully stopped.

Why do Hindus respect Muslims and Muslims don’t?

It is not so much the question of Hindus respecting Muslims and Muslims not respecting Hindus. On the human level, there are Hindus who respect some Muslims and others not, and Muslims respect some Hindus and others not, depending on their character.

The question is rather: why do Hindus say “we respect Islam (and Christianity)” and Muslims (and Christians) do not say “we respect Hinduism.

The reason why Muslims don’t say it is clear. Islam claims to be the only true religions. “Idol worship” (and Hinduism is wrongly considered as idol worship) is especially offensive to their God. So naturally Muslim cannot respect Hinduism. In fact, they even have to fight Hindus:

“Oh believers fight them until there is no more mischief and the Deen of Allah (way of life prescribed by Allah) is established completely” (Quran 8.39)


The “One Truth” of Hinduism (= the Divine Essence is present everywhere) on the other hand expressed itself always in many different streams and they lived side by side peacefully. So not knowing much about dogmatic religions, many Hindus respect them, because these also worship the Divine. However, they don’t know that these religions require blind belief and condemnation of “others”, especially Hindus, into eternal hell.

So naturally, it is rather foolish to respect that which wants to wipe out what you hold dear. (Christians also have the “duty” to convert the whole world to Christianity, because they also consider their religions as “only true”).

It’s easy to see why there is so much chaos in the world…

How does it feel for a westerner to convert to Hinduism?

I recently converted (though my guru would laugh at this word) to Hinduism. Life feels much simpler now. Would love to know about others’ experiences.

It feels great to have escaped the narrow-mindedness of incredible dogmas.


I understand that your guru would laugh at “convert”, because it is rather becoming free from conversion – having been forced as a child to turn to some artificial, blind belief.  It feels like coming back to the natural state of a human being, free to inquire into what is true about us and the universe.

Here I described my experience. “essentially” means, I didn’t take any official step to “become” a Hindu, I simply feel at home in the Hindu tradition and am grateful to it.

~ by Maria Wirth



Click here to post a comment

  • Yes hinduism liberates the mind to fly high. It allows us to believe or not to believe in idol worship, it is not mandatory for a hindu to go to a temple. He can meditate at home, in a forest, on a mountain and know the truth about himself which is the one which matters to him ultimately.

  • I simply feel at home – thats the only thing, that matters…which is exactly how i have been feeling all the while since I was born a Hindu

  • The greatest tennet of Hinduism is that all paths lead to truth is applicable to those who want to follow truth and not on those who says only my way is the answer or is true religion Such people live in ignorance.Thats why there is such a chaos in the world as these people have tried and are still trying to convert others by using all kinds of means including violence to their thoughts. Hinduism sets you free and emphasises truthful Enquiry called “gigyasa”

  • POVERTY AND social discrimination in hinduism is the main cause behind a hindu converted into christian & muslim or any other religion. REASON …..in INDIA 99 % muslim and christian were hindu breed. muslim invaders also converted hindus by FORCE but they less than 25%.

  • You say all paths lead to God and yet you are very critical. Is not God in all men and good and evil everywhere. And surly the British must have done something good. Practice knowledge and when you have tried the truth you can teach. Until then remember to look at your self and examine your motivation. You see God is in everything and everyone. Good. On this we can agree.